Find below our top tips on how to choose influencers for your brand. How to select influencers that are the right fit for your next influencer marketing campaign.

Brought to you by Mau, a Senior Influencer Marketing Specialist at eDigital.


There are tons of ways to influencers fabricate metrics:

  • Buying followers on any social network
  • Buying engagement (likes, retweets, comments) on any social network
  • Buying YouTube views
  • Buying (quality) blog post comments
  • Buying website traffic
  • Rapidly growing social followings via the follow/unfollow technique.

⚡️ Trending today > The best Influencer Marketing Platforms


Before knowing how to work with influencers and get the most out of your influencer marketing budget, you need to know how you are going to cherry-pick the best influencers for your next marketing campaign. 


The most important thing to consider is whether or not the influencer is a perfect match for your brand and demographic. You need to be crystal clear on who your specific audience is because it might not always be who you think.  Imagine you’re selling healthy delivered homemade meals. The first thought is you need to reach food bloggers to work with. No, probably not. Food bloggers are usually talking about the food they make themselves and their readers probably make their own food too. Instead, your audience might be busy people. People who don’t have time to cook. Perhaps mommy bloggers who clearly have a lot on their hands or even interior design bloggers that can use the service to complement their decor. You could even get more specific by zeroing in on people who are health conscious. The bottom line is that you need to find the exact fit in terms of targeting. Some platforms are awesome for this sort of thing (not all). Some allow you to be hyper-specific and narrow down to the right influencers. For example, you can easily search and find maternity bloggers living in Sydney who wear vintage clothing and shop in high-end stores. You can even narrow down to the posts where they talk about the specific aesthetic, products, or brands you’re searching. That’s pretty powerful when it comes to gauging the success of those posts and finding the right bloggers to work with.

⚡️ Popular this month > The world’s top 10 influencers on Instagram

Cherry picking the right influencers can produce hundreds of million views for your brand as seen below on the Walmart’s closet makeover influencer marketing campaign. 

Walmart Influencer campaign on TikTok closet makeover

Walmart Influencer campaign on TikTok closet makeover. Photo: Arielle Mae @arielle_mae


Everyone is going to have some random followers. This is unavoidable. What you want to avoid is people who have more than 50%-60% randos and do this exercise for at least for your top 20 influencers you are spending most of your budget with. Look for blocks of odd profiles because these fake followers will show up as one big group. Too many Russian-language profile descriptions or English words that do not make any sense are “red flags” for fake followers.

You will also like > How to craft an Employee Influencer program


If you see someone with intensely sporadic engagement on social posts, then that’s probably the best indicator because when someone purchases engagement, they usually have to specify one of their posts that will receive the engagement (rather than spreading the engagement out across posts in a more natural way. If someone is getting no engagement for most of their posts, then all of a sudden there is one post with 1,000 retweets, you might want to go ahead and question that. Scan through blog comments instead of just looking at comment counts. I’ve seen some bloggers comment like 44 times on their own posts without any real engagement, so it’s pretty easy to detect. Check for spammy comments that are totally irrelevant to the conversation. “My cousin makes $50,000 a week by filling out surveys….” Or “Check out my homemade Viagra…” While most bloggers have put up spam filters to keep out all the random viagra-peddlers, you’ll see some bloggers that have unusually high amounts of spam comments. It’s important to just glance through the comment section for at least 10 or 20 of your top 100 influencers to make sure that the engagement is legit.

Marketers are using > How to write the best Influencer brief + template


Ask the influencer to tell you brands they’ve worked with in the past. Are any of those brands repeat clients? Are those clients the same size and industry as yours? If there are a few repeat customers, you are likely to have found a legit successful influencer.

Editor’s pick > The world’s top 10 Youtube influencers


Choosing the right influencers is essential for effectively reaching and engaging your target audience, building credibility and trust.

Picking the right influencers for your brand ensures authenticity and relevance, maximise content quality and expanding reach and engagement.

The right influencers for your next marketing campaign should align with campaign goals, fostering long-term relationships, and achieving measurable results.

By investing time and resources into influencer selection, brands can maximise the ROI of their influencer marketing efforts and drive sustainable growth and success.

eDigital can help you conceptualise, plan, develop, run and optimise successful digital marketing campaigns that generate leads and sales for your brand.

Our digital marketing services include:

  • Strategic planning for social media and other digital marketing channels.
  • Online advertising management and optimisation: Google Ads Search, Display, Re-marketing and social media advertising.
  • Training: social media marketing training and digital marketing training. 
  • SEO strategy and execution. Including content development:articles, stories, eye-catching and SEO-optimised visuals.
  • Celebrity and influencer marketing campaign strategy. 
  • Brand development. Logo creation, brand personality development and design of marketing materials.
  • Consumer contests/competitions/giveaways.
  • Email marketing. Dip sequence design and deployment. 
  • Conversion rate optimisation. It is also called “path to purchase” optimisation. 

Contact us today and start boosting your leads and sales.

Hundreds of marketers have supported us with their generous donations. Please donate today! or join 5k+ marketers receiving our e-newsletter.

Final note: Want to reduce customer acquisition costs and dependency on paid media? eDigital‘s marketing strategy training will unmercifully review your marketing, help you build a marketing engine with channels and assets you own, stir your team’s thinking, bring new ideas for new conversion paths and boost customer lifetime value.


was brought to you by Mau
cat laptop rug book red glasses illustration

Mau is one of the most popular marketing consultants offering the best marketing strategy training and the best social media training. Top marketers use Mau’s popular Digital Marketing Plan and Social Media Plan templates

Book Mau for your next training day or join 5k+ marketers receiving Mau‘s e-newsletter